The full pdf of mogoeng mogoengs nkandla judgement, as well as. Minister of police briefing mr j selfe da indicated that on 23 june 2015, he had tabled a submission on behalf of the da in which it was argued that, according to the constitution and the public protector act, the findings and remedial actions of the public protector cannot be summarily rejected. Republic of south africa, his excellency j g zuma, at nkandla in the. A pawn in president jacob zumas neverending cabinet reshuffles, nhleko was, surprisingly, rewarded with another position in the executive in april after a disastrous and controversial spell as minister of police. The list of anc members who said zuma owes nothing for nkandla.
The public protectors report was very clear that the minister of police was to. Police minister nathi nhlekos nkandla report, in which he introduced south africa to the term firepool, was factually correct, he told mps on thursday. Nhleko pretty fine with his nkandla report, sticks by it. President not liable for nkandla security upgrades. A mass protest in front of parliament on the day that minister nhleko willpresent this report to the relevant committee of parliament and on the next day president zuma addresses parliament. Johannesburg the da will use the ad hoc committee considering police minister nathi nhlekos report on nkandla to reject its findings, party leader mmusi maimane said on sunday. Mogoeng mogoengs full nkandla judgment biblical david takes on. Nhleko pretty fine with his nkandla report, sticks by it janet heard 20160423 11. A report of the public protector found that zuma unduly benefited from these.
Police minister nathi nhleko says the only matter he is pursuing against mcbride is the socalled rendition matter. Da mp john steenhuisen had asked for an amendment to the report and provided at least 20 changes but this was rejected by the majority of members the ad hoc committee had earlier in the month given its approval to police minister nathi nhlekos report on the nkandla homestead, despite objections from its opposition members. In his presentation he reported interalia as follows. The public protector on wednesday released her longawaited report on the security upgrades at president jacob zumas private nkandla homestead. United front response to the nhleko report on nkandla. Secure in comfort a report of the march 2014 public protector. In her letter, madonsela says she finds his reasoning difficult to understand. Apart from the release of a statement by the presidency on 03. Now minister of police, nathi nhleko, has been implicated in another scandal involving a woman, a former kzn correctional services deputy director and the mother of his love child, who was. Police minister nkosinathi nhleko will brief parliament on his nkandla report at 1. Public protector the public protector, advocate thuli madonsela, notes police minister nathi nhlekos report to parliament on the security upgrades at president jacob zumas private residence in nkandla, kwazulunatal.
Sacc appalled by nhleko nkandla report ng kerk vrystaat. Police minister nhleko ruled that the president will not have to pay back any. Nhleko s report stems from a recommendation by the. Economic freedom fighters v speaker of the national assembly and others. President zuma submits report on nkandla security upgrades.
The public protector believes the shortcomings of the ministers report pdf are partly due to. Minister of public works appointed a task team of officials from the. In terms of your report, mr president, the minister. The anc in in the nkandla ad hoc committee predictably rubberstamped the nhleko report that we assert should have never even been considered in place of the public protectors report in the first instance. Nhleko served in parliament as chairperson of the portfolio committee on public service and administration, chairperson of the african national congress anc caucus. Pdf icon report by the minister of police to parliament on. Minister nhleko must understand that what was expected of him, as a employee of jacob zuma, was not to determine whether the president must pay or not. Issued by the minister of police nkosinathi nhleko, may 28 2015. His professional career includes serving as the head of the special anticorruption unit in the department of public service and administration, deputy municipal manager for the umhlathuze municipality and as regional.
Mr nkosinathi nhleko previously served as the minister of public works. Thursday, 28 may 2015 was earmarked as dday for president jacob zuma. Jesting about the scandalous nkandla issue and investigation during his response to parliament was. Why nhleko sweated buckets over his nkandla report the. She is of the view that minister nhleko gave the matter his best and that he. Cape town the ad hoc committee considering police minister nathi nhlekos widelypanned report on president jacob zumas nkandla home. Police minister nkosinathi nhlekos brief to parliament regarding his nkandla report scheduled for 7pm on wednesday has been postponed at the last minute. As police minister nathi nhleko continued his ridiculous attempts to justify not only the nkandla spending but his whitewashed report into it, south africans were introduced to a soweto man named. Nhleko determination on nkandla should be set aside says da. At a press briefing punctuated by educational videos on the use and meaning of various features at nkandla, nhleko revealed his conclusion. Jesting about the scandalous nkandla issue and investigation during his response to parliament was an undeniably low point in the presidency, of which there are becoming too many. President jacob zuma does not have to pay back any of the money. President jacob zuma doesnt have to pay back the money. According to reports, 198 members of parliament mps voted in favour of adopting the report, while 93 mps voted against it.
Madonsela hits out at shortcomings in nkandla report. Ad hoc committee on police ministers report on nkandla. Why nhleko sweated buckets over his nkandla report. Nhleko was presenting his report into the nkandla saga in cape. Police minister nathi nhleko implicated in public prote. A meeting of the ad hoc committee on police ministers report on nkandla committee held on 11 june 2015, lead by mr c frolick anc.
Good morning ladies and gentlemen at its meeting of 4 december 20, cabinet resolved to release to the public the ministerial task team report on the security installation at. Thuli madonsela, notes minister of police nathi nhlekos report to parliament on the security upgrades at president jacob zumas private residence in nkandla, kwazulunatal. Nkandla report crafted to exonerate president zuma the release of police minister nathi nhlekos nkandla report yesterday, and its conclusion that president zuma is cleared of all obligation to pay back any of the costs associated with the upgrade of his personal. Thuli madonsela strikes back with force by stephen grootes november 20 in the court of public opinion, legal papers. In a report to parliament last week, zuma said nhleko had to decide whether the president is liable for any contribution in respect of the security upgrades at his private home in nkandla. On 21 july 2015, the minister of police, minister n p nhleko presented his report to the ad hoc committee on the security upgrades at the nkandla, the private residence of the president. The secretariat can only be relevant and provide the minister with meaningful support if there is political will to empower it independently. The freedom front plus has laid a complaint against the minister of police, nathi nhleko, and the minister of public works, thulas nxesi, with the public protector as well as the ethics committee of parliament for misleading parliament. Economic freedom fighters v speaker of the national assembly.
She is of the view that minister nhleko gave the matter his best and that he applied his mind to the issues at hand. The private home of former south african president jacob zuma, situated about 24 km 15 mi. Da to challenge police ministers determination on nkandla. Nhleko should have spent more time galvanising the civilian secretariat for the police.
A claim is made in minister nhlekos report, which incorrectly states that the. Today police minister nathi nhleko released his report in response to public protector thuli madonselas investigation into zumas spending of public money on his private homestead, nkandla. The release of police minister nathi nhlekos nkandla. Why was the nkandla report postponed at the last minute.
Economic freedom fighters v speaker of the national. Ensure that no further security measures are installed at the presidents private residence at nkandla. Zuma doesnt have to pay back a cent report the mail. Police, nathi nhleko, into the presidents liability for the upgrades to his private residence at nkandla. On 19 march 2014, she released her socalled nkandla report, which found that some of. Police minister nathi nhleko triggered a political storm on thursday in a report that absolved president jacob zuma from repaying any money for the security upgrades to his nkandla home. Democratic alliance v speaker of the national assembly and others 2016 zacc 11 is a major judgment of the constitutional court of south africa which finds that president jacob zuma breached the south african constitution by failing to implement the recommendations in the public protectors nkandla report. Public protector thuli madonsela has hit back at police minister nkosinathi nhlekos nkandla report.
Public protector the public protector, advocate thuli madonsela, notes police minister nathi nhleko s report to parliament on the security upgrades at president jacob zumas private residence in nkandla, kwazulunatal. Madonsela responds to nhlekos nkandla report corruption watch. Police minister nathi nhleko yesterday gave his report back on the nkandla upgrades. Durban public protector thuli madonsela has blasted a report by police minister nathi nhleko on nkandla, saying it is unnecessary, has no legal basis and is riddled with mistakes. Police minister nathi nhleko treated the media and live television viewers to a surprise demonstration on how to use a firepool and why nkandla needs a. Police minister releases the nkandla report youtube. Letter from president zuma to advocate madonsela pdf. Nkosinathi phiwayinkosi thamsanqa nhleko, popularly known as nathi nhleko, is a former south african minister of police. Secure in comfort a report of the march 2014 public protector 6 by the mail and guardian in an article titled zumas r 65 million nkandla splurge. Perhaps he was struck by prescience, aware that his report by the minister of police to parliament on security upgrades at the nkandla private residence of the president would make him a laughing stock.
Police minister nathi nhleko is expected to give a comprehensive response to the recommendations of parliaments nkandla ad hoc committee. He holds a diploma in labour law from the graduate institute of management and technology. A legal challenge to overturn nhlekos decision and report. Police minister nathi nhleko s nkandla report, in which he introduced south africa to the term firepool, was factually correct, he told mps on thursday. Read the public protectors full nkandla report the citizen. The report the ministers had compiled on nkandla found that all the upgrades at nkandla had. The ad hoc committee on nkandla should set aside the determination by the minister of police nathi nhleko as president jacob zuma did not have the authority to commission the report the. Zuma doesnt have to pay back the money corruption watch. Parly committee officially adopts nhlekos report on nkandla. The legal enforcement of the report of the public protector on the nkandla matter. Minister of police and minister of public works on nkandla security. Sacc appalled by nhleko nkandla report president zumas response to parliament this week has left the leadership of the south african council of churches appalled. On 28 may 2015, police minister nkosinathi nhleko, who was appointed by zuma on 25 may 2014, released his report on nkandla which found that the swimming pool, cattle kraal, chicken run, visitors centre and amphitheatre were needed security features and concluded that zuma does not owe the south african taxpayers anything.
On 28 may 2015, police minister nkosinathi nhleko, who was appointed by zuma on 25 may. The parliamentary committee scrutinising the expenditure of r246 million to upgrade president jacob zumas home has officially adopted police minister nathi nhlekos report and findings. Downloadsnkandla security upgrade report august 2014. They say south africa works because of public works but whether public works will continue to work under nathi nhleko remains to be seen. Mr nkosinathi nhleko, minister of police, said that the security evaluation report of. Sa police minister sweats over nkandla report the standard.
889 696 378 746 739 152 481 547 687 218 459 1006 1030 58 732 661 594 436 965 413 1373 1468 255 701 540 319 1302 947 1459 562 1101 57 599 1 1181 1463 992